Guide to concrete repair results from recognition of that need. Introduction cavitation in hydraulic structures is well known. If each of these design elements is carefully considered while engineering a hydraulic system, the risk of cavitation damaging or destroying hydraulic pumps should decrease significantly. The potential for cavitation damage can be determined using design aids, such as reclamations engineering monograph no 42. The book includes a section on cavitation in hydraulic structures and a concise introduction to the physics of cavitation and application to hydraulic structures. Cavitation in hydraulic structures and turbomachinery. Numerical detection of cavitation damage on dam spillway. International water power and dam construction, 35 11 1983, pp. Usually associated with powered, rotating equipment, cavitation also occurs in stationary hydraulic structures involving both small and large scale flows. It is often neglected or ignored in the design and construction of hydraulic structures, and the results can be costly. Cavitation corrosion an overview sciencedirect topics. Surface irregularity and water speed creates bubbles.
Erosion of concrete in hydraulic structures 21or3 fig. Hydraulic cavitation is usually an undesirable phenomenon since it can damage the concrete surface of a chute spillway. Cavitation damage at, or adjacent to, control gates can usually be repaired with epoxy bonded epoxy mortar, polymer concrete, or epoxybonded replacement concrete. Cavitation in fluid machinery and hydraulic structures. Operating experience and previous experimental work suggest that cavitation damage can be greatly reduced and, in some cases, eliminated by entrained air in the water. The impact of cavitation on a pump cavitation causes pump performance deterioration, mechanical damage, noise and vibration which can ultimately lead to pump failure. The simple enumeration of some types of equipment, structures, or. It reveals also characteristics of cavitation damage in the form of dents in stainless steel which appears not to have been documented. Cavitation damaqe in hydraulic structures is abstract a function of. The damaging effects of cavitation erosion may be reduced or stopped by decreasing the critical cavitation number e. Pdf cavitation in hydraulic structures researchgate.
Cavitation from surface irregularities in high velocity. Based on these factors, five different damage levels from no cavitation damage to major cavitation damage have been determined. This paper presents a classification of cavitation damage levels on spillway surface. Cavitation erosion is a result of complex flow characteristics of water over concrete surfaces. Hydraulic research of aerators on tunnel spillways sciencedirect.
Erosion can range in extent from a relatively minor amount of pitting after many years of operation to disastrous failure of large and expensive structures in a. On the mechanism of cavitation damage caltechauthors. Finally occurrence of cavitation damage to the doosti dam spillway was investigated. Whitesides, cpe, pe 2 cavitation can, and often does, occur in any situation where fluid is moving in relation to a solid surface. In hydraulic structures, water contains air bubbles and various types of impurities of many different sizes. It is designed to serve as a companion document to the standard specifications for repair of concrete included in appendix a of this guide. Cavitation in elements of hydraulic structures and methods of. Russell rochambeau, ifps hs, is engineering manager at valin corp. Damage andor failures are often the most common study drivers.
Rahmeyer cavitation damage can occur to almost any type of hydraulic structure. Hydraulic jump grout curtain design flood uplift pressure cavitation damage these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. Cavitation was first explained in 1917 by the english physicist, lord rayleigh, as he was studying a mysterious metal erosion on ship propellers. Design of spillway aeration devices to prevent cavitation. The method was applied to data of the shahid abbaspour dam. Cavitation characteristics of offsetintoflow and effect of. Four key hydropower projects of different dam types near the epicenter withstood the most severe tests, sustaining only repairable damage. Ryszard daniel, tim paulus, in lock gates and other closures in hydraulic projects, 2019. Thus, for proper values of flow rate and tunnel pressure at 0, the local pressure near point c will drop to the vapor. Damaged and undamaged valves were then inserted in a hydraulic test loop to observe the flow rate and pressure drop across the valves.
Hydraulic pumps and turbines are interesting in that. The first cavitation damage at hoover dam and experiences else where prompted researchers to tighten flowsurface tolerance re quirements. Hydraulic structures are subject to varying loads of a more or less cyclic character. Abrasive effects observed in concrete hydraulic surfaces of dams and application of repair materials 21 describe the wear by the abrasive action of fluids satisfaction suspended solids occurring as coatings on hydraulic structures of channels and spillways. In the interim, many perceptions have changed about the causes of cavitation. Damage from cavitation has been reported in several hydraulic structures, including open channel spillways, bottom outlets in dams, highhead gates and gate slots, and energy dissipators with hydraulicjump stilling basins.
When subjected to higher pressure, these cavities, called bubbles or voids, collapse and can generate an intense shock wave. The cavitation and erosion resistance of 21 thermal spray coatings and four weld repair materials were investigated in the laboratory using cavitation jet and slurry erosion testing. Relationship between cavitation structures and cavitation. The cavitation damage in the spillways was first noticed in the period between 1970 and 1980 through. It gives a physical explanation of the processes involved in damage occurrence and of the in. Chute or tunnel spillways for high dams involve highvelocity flow, so cavitation damage may occur if projections or depressions such as cylindrical and.
Figure 1 shows the erosions in the discharge hole of liujiaxia hydropower station and spillway of wanjiazhai hydropower station in the yellow river. Presentation on chute spillways and bottom outlets, cavitation damage may occur at clear water velocities of between 12 to 15 ms. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Pdf cavitation in hydraulic structures eric j lesleighter. Cavitation damaqe in hydraulic structures is abstract a function of the cavitation potential, the duration of the operation, the boundary roughness and alignment, and the strength of the materials from which the boundary is constructed, a method of locating sites of cavitation damage in spillways is presented. Cavitation is a phenomenon in which rapid changes of pressure in a liquid lead to the formation of small vaporfilled cavities, in places where the pressure is relatively low. Hydraulic practice demonstrated that severe cavitation damage occurred even for irregularities of a few millimetres.
Fast water and irregular surface areas of concrete can result in cavitation. Thermal spray and weld repair alloys for the repair of. Dec 23, 2019 erosion on the overflow surface of discharge structure commonly occurs due to cavitation and abrasion at high speed flow. Airwater flow in hydraulic structures december 1980 6. Cavitation in fluid machinery and hydraulic structures cavitation in fluid machinery and hydraulic structures arndt, r e a 19810101 00. Best practices in dam and levee safety risk analysis. Hydraulic structures an overview sciencedirect topics. Relationship between cavitation structures and cavitation damage. According to statistical data, 70% of discharge structures of large hydraulic projects in china suffer from cavitation erosion and abrasion damage wang et al. Cavitation in centrifugal pumps and prediction thereof. Cavitation can affect performance, for example through increased drag of hydronautical vehicles, limitations on the. Air entrainment and air demand in the spillway tunnel at. Abrasive effects observed in concrete hydraulic surfaces of.
Cavitation damage to concrete structures and its prevention. Lesleighter e j, cavitation in hydraulic structures 1. Designed in roughness can protect cavitation prone surfaces. The velocity near point c is much higher than the average velocity in the tunnel upstream, and the streamlines near point c are curved. Since the topic of cavitation in fluid machinery in hydraulic struc tures cuts across many disciplines we cannot provide an indepth annu. Perhaps the issue we are most concerned about with hydraulic structures is the possibility of cavitation erosion or damage. Perhaps the occurrence is, but how well its character. Hydraulic valve failure caused by cavitation a client recently asked me to advise them on the possibility of repairing a large hydraulic valve off a 400ton excavator, used in opencut mining. These loads can be generated not only by periodic differential water heads on, for example, navigation lock gates, but also by waves, forces from drive systems, and other actions. An early case of cavitation damage was reported for hooverdamwarnock1947withinandjustbelowits50 8vertical. The development of cavitation in a liquid flow is characterized by a phase change from liquid to vapor at almost constant temperature. Effects of cavitation damage on the hydraulic characteristics. After performing such repairs, it might be a good idea to apply a 100percent solids epoxy coating to the concrete, beginning at the gate frame and extending downstream 5 to 10 feet. Concrete surfaces downstream from high head outlet gates are particularly vulnerable to cavitation damage.
For damage to occur, the rate of water flow normally needs to exceed 40 feet per second. Cavitation in hydraulic structuresbridging the gap between the. In arch dams, they can also be placed on the body due to the shortage of space. Investigation of cavitation damage levels on spillways. It applies the laws of similitude to the use of physical models to improve hydraulic design and computer programs for the numerical solution of unsteady flow in closed and open channels. Tests on soft metal show initial cavitation damage in the form of tiny craters. Numerical modeling of spillway aerators in highhead dams. As a result, hydraulic structures have been built for years. This guide first discusses reclamations methodology for concrete repair. The cavitation index of the damaged and the undamaged gate valves was also calculated to predict the likelihood of cavitation. Highvelocity flow often occurs on spillways, particularly for high dams, which can cause severe cavitation damage to the hydraulic structures. The velocity of water that impinges at the surface point is one of the causes of cavitation.
Hamiltonpreventing cavitation damage to hydraulic structures, part one j. Pdf cavitation in chutes and spillways semantic scholar. The valves hydraulic loss coefficient was then calculated and compared. The flow conditions which dictate the various cavitation preventat i on. Two important factors influencing cavitation damage have been considered in this study, flow velocity and cavitation index.
Cavitation characteristics of offsetintoflow and effect of aeration. Erosion on the overflow surface of discharge structure commonly occurs due to cavitation and abrasion at high speed flow. Water and power resources service engineering and research center il. In order to numerically predict the potential cavitation of a highspeed flow in a chute spillway, a compound risk assessment is proposed by combining probabilistic analysis with a computational fluid dynamics cfd technique. The types of surfaces often encountered in construction are shown and many examples of cavitation damage induced by the irregularities are shown. Introduction numerous studies have been made of the cavitation proc ess and the mechanism of cavitation damage. A proposal of a cavitation erosion model, which is. Physical and numerical model studies on cavitation. The microscopic air bubbles or impurities in the water are necessary to initiate cavitation. Vibration is a common symptom of cavitation, and many times the first sign of an issue. Interesting facts and myths about cavitation 2012 randall w. Of the thermal spray coatings, stellite 6 deposited by the high velocity oxyfuel hvof process had the lowest cavitation rate 11. Wear 257 2004 11761184 relationship between cavitation structures and cavitation damage matev.
Prediction of cavitation damage on spillway using knearest. The hydraulic valve in question was a spooltype directional control. Pf l h dd performance loss head drop material damage cavitation erosion vibrations noise vapor lock if suction pressure drops bl b kbelow breakoff l ff value visser et al, 1998. Part 1part 1 what is cavitation cont what is cavitation cont. Webb allischalmers fluid products company ubtib hannover 89 101 886 292. The paper discusses cavitation in a high head gated outlet works, not simply as a casestudy but a rare opportunity to compare results from major instrumentation programs in both model studies and the field installation. Experimental study on the mechanism of the combined action of. Cavitation damage to hydraulic structures william j. Webb allischalmers fluid products company ubtib hannover 89. Irregularities in flow surfaces of hydraulic structures operating at high velocities have been the source of serious damage by cavitation. Numerical prediction and risk analysis of hydraulic. Proceedings of the institution of civil engineers water, maritime and energy, volume 124, issue 2, 1 jun 1997 95103 discussion. Cavitationdamage studies, which have been carried out in liquid toluene and in a helium atmosphere, show that chemical effects can be, at most, of seconday significance.
This paper discusses the different types, causes, and. Closer analysis, however, shows that the cavitation is associated with surface roughness or isolated asperities in the structures surfaces. The velocity near point c is much higher than the average velocity in the tunnel upstream, and the. Vibration causes problems for many pump components, including the shaft, bearings and seals. Effect of entrained air on cavitation damage canadian. Experiments were carried out with a special high head test facility in. Unchecked cavitation damage can erode through a spillway lining, compromising the foundation below.
Some methods of preventing cavitation damage, other than aeration grooves, are discussed. It then addresses the more common causes of damage. Lesleighter e j, cavitation in hydraulic structures 3 international symposium on modelprototype correlation of hydraulic structures, august 1988 entirely satisfactory performance. The most severe cavitation damage occurred in 1993 during an estimated.
23 1324 211 593 1582 1307 845 272 1309 138 1396 1585 611 1532 497 125 1406 1196 1486 1069 815 1423 275 1508 649 916 488 1023 575 1049 1511 1285 367 1237 1535 217 646 1342 1378 441 1430 717 465 1284 327 960 472 1352